Skip to main content

Choosing a spectrophotometer can look complicated. Handheld versus scanning. M0 versus M1. Small versus large aperture. Manual versus automated. Then there is software compatibility, profiling support, verification, quality control, and pressroom use.

The good news is that most purchasing decisions can be reduced to four questions: what are you measuring, which measurement conditions do you need, how do you want to measure, and what software must the instrument support?

4 factors for choosing a spectrophotometer

Match the instrument to the work, not the other way around. Each factor links to the section that covers it.

  1. What are you measuring? Press control, proofing, ICC profiling, wide-format, or textured media. The application decides the aperture size and the measurements you need.
  2. Which measurement conditions do you need? M0, M1, M2, or M3 under ISO 13655. Papers with optical brightening agents need M1, and most offset sheet papers now contain them.
  3. How do you want to measure? Handheld, strip scanning, or automated measurement. The number of patches you read, and how often, sets the answer.
  4. What software and workflow must it support? Your RIP, ICC profiling, G7 calibration, and verification software. Confirm the instrument is supported before you buy it.

1. What are you measuring?

Start with the application. A commercial offset pressroom has very different needs from a proofing department, packaging converter, wide-format operation, or color-management lab.

An offset pressroom may need to evaluate:

  • Solid ink density
  • TVI / dot gain
  • Trapping
  • Gray balance
  • G7 compliance
  • Spot colors
  • L*a*b* values
  • Spectral data

A proofing or color-management department may be focused on:

  • ICC profiling
  • Device characterization
  • Media white point
  • OBA detection
  • G7 verification
  • Color difference
  • Large profiling targets

Wide-format environments can be even more varied, with coated paper, vinyl, canvas, backlit media, textiles, and rigid or textured substrates all entering the workflow. The broader the substrate mix, the more important instrument flexibility becomes.

Aperture size matters

A small aperture is useful for compact patches and control strips. A larger aperture can improve repeatability on textured or nonuniform materials such as canvas, textiles, scrim vinyl, and rough uncoated stocks. The instrument should fit the application, not the other way around.

2. What measurement conditions do you need?

This is one of the most important, and most frequently overlooked, parts of the decision. Modern print standards rely on the ISO 13655 measurement conditions.

  • M0 — Legacy measurement condition with an undefined UV component.
  • M1 — D50-compatible measurement condition with controlled UV content.
  • M2 — UV-cut condition that suppresses fluorescence from optical brightening agents (OBAs).
  • M3 — Polarized measurement used to reduce the influence of surface reflections and wet/dry differences.

If your operation works with modern GRACoL, G7, ISO-based workflows, or papers containing OBAs, M1 capability is especially important. OBAs absorb ultraviolet energy and re-emit part of it in the blue region, which changes the apparent paper white. Roughly 90 percent of offset sheet papers contain OBAs now, and your proofing paper should match this condition.

The ability to compare M1 and M2 is also useful diagnostically. If the substrate changes noticeably between the two conditions, fluorescence is contributing to the measured white point.

That can affect how you choose or evaluate a print condition. For example, whether the workflow is better aligned with a modern M1-based characterization such as GRACoL 2013 or a legacy M0-based condition such as GRACoL 2006. GRACoL 2006 would be a good fit for non-OBA environments using an M0 measurement mode.

Before buying, make sure the instrument supports the measurement conditions required by your customers, process-control standards, and color-management workflow.

3. How do you want to measure?

The third factor is productivity. The best measurement technology is not very useful if the workflow is too slow for the volume of work you do.

Handheld measurement

Handheld spectrophotometers are extremely versatile. They can be used at the press, in the ink room, on the production floor, or in the color lab:

  • Spot measurements
  • Press control
  • Spot-color evaluation
  • Substrate measurements
  • G7 verification
  • Troubleshooting

The tradeoff is speed. Manually reading hundreds or thousands of profiling patches can become time-consuming.

Scanning instruments

Scanning instruments let the operator measure an entire row of patches in one pass. For profiling and verification work, that can be a major productivity improvement:

  • ICC profiling targets
  • G7 targets
  • IT8 charts
  • P2P targets
  • Large verification charts

For many color-management departments, a scanning spectrophotometer offers the best balance between flexibility and speed. But for most, a handheld works just fine. Some have the luxury of having both in house.

Automated measurement

Automated tables and printer-integrated systems provide the highest repeatability and reduce operator influence. They are particularly valuable when profiling, verification, or certification targets are measured frequently.

Two operators can vary slightly in positioning, pressure, speed, or technique. Automation removes much of that variability and can make routine color-control work far more consistent.

4. What software and workflow must it support?

A spectrophotometer is only useful if it works with the software you actually use. In many cases, this should be confirmed before the instrument is purchased. Not every RIP supports every device. Check before buying.

A device can have excellent measurement technology and still be the wrong choice if the RIP, profiling package, G7 software, or process-control platform does not support it.

Verify compatibility with:

  • RIP software
  • ICC profiling software
  • G7 calibration software
  • Print-quality verification systems
  • Press-control systems
  • Spot-color libraries
  • Color-management platforms

That may include environments such as Fiery XF, ONYX, PrintFactory, ColorLogic, ChromaChecker, Curve, Heidelberg Prinect, Kodak Prinergy, Esko, GMG, and other production systems.

Do not stop at a simple "supported / not supported" answer. Confirm exactly what the software can do with the instrument. Some applications may support a device for verification but not profiling, or for manual readings but not automated scanning. Driver support, available measurement modes, chart-reading capability, and automation support can all matter.

Do Not Choose on Price Alone

Purchase price matters, but the least expensive instrument is not always the lowest-cost solution. Consider the total cost of:

  • Operator time
  • Measurement speed
  • Repeated measurements
  • Software compatibility problems
  • Calibration and recertification
  • Service
  • Downtime

An instrument that saves 20 or 30 minutes every time a large target is measured can quickly offset a higher purchase price. The same is true of a device that works reliably across multiple RIPs and color-management applications without workarounds.

The Best Instrument Is the One That Fits the Workflow

There is no single spectrophotometer that is perfect for every printing operation. A press operator measuring control strips has different requirements from a color-management specialist building ICC profiles. A proofing department has different needs from a packaging printer, and a wide-format operation may need to measure substrates that would never appear in a conventional commercial-print environment.

Before choosing an instrument, answer these four questions:

  1. What are we measuring?
  2. Which measurement conditions do we need?
  3. How much manual, scanning, or automated measurement do we need?
  4. Which software and production systems must the instrument support?

Once those questions are answered, the list of suitable instruments gets much smaller, and the right choice becomes much clearer.

A spectrophotometer should not simply be another measurement device. It should become an integrated, reliable part of the color-management workflow.

Getting Started

We'd love to help you make these critical decisions. Contact Bill Owen at Alder Color Solutions:
billo@aldertech.com

About the Author

Bill Owen of Alder Color Solutions

Bill Owen

Lead Color Specialist, Alder Color Solutions

Bill is an Idealliance-certified G7 Expert and founder of Elevated Color, with more than 45 years in prepress, printing, and color management — including over 25 years dedicated to helping printers achieve predictable, repeatable color across commercial, packaging, wide-format, offset, digital, and inkjet work.

He specializes in G7 implementation, ICC profiling, press and monitor calibration, proofing systems, and workflow standardization, with deep experience across RIPs including EFI Fiery XF, PrintFactory, ChromaChecker, Onyx, Caldera, and Xitron Navigator, and platesetter workflows such as Agfa Apogee, Kodak Prinergy, Esko, and Heidelberg Prinect. His work has appeared in PRINTING United, Idealliance, and WhatTheyThink.

Questions? Contact Bill at Alder Color Solutions: Email: billo@aldertech.com
Phone: 720-933-4413